Digging Deeper

Now that we've gotten some people that could be our "mystery portrait" it's time to dig deeper. Lets look more closely at our candidates and our unknown man to look at their individual features. More after the read more!

Here are close-ups of the men we have as possibles' eyes.  Listed in the order that follows:
1. Thos. Reed.
2. Unidentified Man from Our Library
3. H.H. Holmes
4. Bainbridge Wadleigh

Lets look at their noses:

1. Thos Reed.
2. Unidentified Man
3. H.H. Holmes
4. Bainbridge Wadleigh

What are your thoughts? Do any of these men look strikingly similar when you look up close? Don't think any of these men cut it? Do you have your own suggestion or photo that may help us identify our photograph?

Who is he?

Edit to add: Higher quality pictures of our portrait, including the jewel at his tie that could help in finding his identity!